Illegal International Adoption

In America, we often see adoption as a good Samaritan act, but is it always so? After seeing an episode on adoption in a favorite show of mine, “Traffickers,” I began to do my own research and question this. Adoption usually has good intentions and can be very beneficial to young children, but it can also be a horrifying system.

When there is a demand, there is a supply, even if one isn’t readily available. Americans are willing to pay a large sum of money to “save” a child through adoption. Some adoption agencies and traffickers, especially in the Congo, take advantage of this. Teachers will go out into villages and offer parents an American or European education, at the end of which the children will supposedly return. The parents, often illiterate themselves, want the best education possible for their children, so they sign a document they can’t even read. Little do they know, by signing this document, they are giving away their children. The parents never see the children again, but the teachers and adoption agencies receive a grand payment.

I was horrified as I watched birth families come to this realization. When they confront the teachers, they are denied any information on where the children have gone. Many of the children are given new names and fake adoption papers so that American parents and adoption agencies feel as if they are helping the child. Little do they know that the parents’ death certificates have been faked.

Such adoption practices have many similarities to human trafficking. First off, both thrive in times of war and conflict. Secondly, there is a huge wealth gap in between the countries of origin and destination. Many adopted children and victims of human trafficking come from places such as Guatemala and Venezuela, and end up in places such as the US and UK. This is an indicator that poverty is a motivator in both businesses, especially since each adoption can bring in $25,000-$50,000 of profit, making adoption fraud very appealing. Also, both are usually found in places where corruption is thoroughly ingrained in the government.

So is illegal adoption human trafficking? According to the US government, no. This may be partly because our country makes a lot of money through the business, or maybe because they feel adoptive parents are unable to face the possible reality of their child’s background. Or maybe they do not recognize it as trafficking for more technical reasons; human trafficking must meet the three criterias of Acts, Means, and Purpose. The Act of this is basically kidnapping, and the Means of transportation can often be awful for the children. However, illegal adoption technically does not meet the Purpose criteria, since most children are not explicitly exploited and are ultimately given a “better” life.

At the same time however, measures taken against illegal adoption can harm some children. Srey Powers, an adopted child from Cambodia, remembers extreme abuses and awful labor conditions from her original home. However, two years after she was adopted, the US closed Cambodian adoptions because of “corruption.” What about all the other children from Cambodia who, unlike Srey, will never get their second chance?

This is obviously a very complicated situation, with no perfect solution. I’m not going to try and offer one either. My main goal in writing this is to spread awareness. I, personally, think I would like to adopt as an adult, but now that I know this information, I will carefully select a child whose agency I have done much research on.

As a 17 year old, I obviously do not have any real experience with parenthood, but I would still like to inform those of all ages who are curious about adoption. Adoption is a wonderful practice, if done correctly.

5 comments

  1. I’m an adoptee from China and I have to say your argument is lacking at best. My parents adopted me, not because they were being “good Samaritans,” but because they wanted a child and my mother could not birth one on her own. The fact that you compared adoption to human trafficking is seriously offensive. There is a big difference between adoption and the latter that you are referencing. According to mljaadoptions.com the payment the parents pay is for the service of the agencies, cost of travel, and safekeeping of the adoptee. But like this organization states, “Payment does not produce child.” The payments one pays in human trafficking is to gain the control over another person for explotation. That is not the same as paying for a child’s past care and an adoption agent’s work. Families adopt because they want to start a family. I wasn’t brought over to America at eleven months old because I was a charity case and my privledged parents felt bad for me. Unless you are an adoptee or a family member of an adoptee with upfront experience, I don’t think you have the liberty to speak about whether adoption is good or not. Also, you didn’t cite any sources.
    www. mljadoptions.com

    Like

  2. Just some general comments here…we all have the liberty to write blog posts and opinion pieces on most anything we choose; that is what the first amendment is all about, and that is why we are at times exposed to ideas that we reject or that we find offensive. Furthermore, it is not common practice to cite sources in opinion pieces and blogs, but it is fine to ask for sources in a reply or extended discussion. The fact that this topic evokes powerful emotion indicates that it is indeed worthy of exploration.
    In today’s climate it seems that we are quick to take offense and to view issues through our own personal lenses. It is my sincere hope that a dialogue can be opened here. A respectful exchange of ideas between people who have different points of view is a sign of maturity and is indeed a cornerstone of democracy.
    ATS

    Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s